The concept of Community Gardens in a digital context represents a collaborative ecosystem where members contribute and grow together, much like a traditional garden but focused on digital or intellectual contributions instead of agricultural produce. In this digital garden, the community uses a unique type of token, often referred to as a "seed," which serves as a redeemable non-fungible token (NFT). These seeds can be "planted," that is, invested or spent within the community to foster growth and generate value.

Earning and Using Seeds

Seeds are directly tied to a community member's contributions and the respect they garner within the community. This respect is quantified through a point or token system—individuals earn respect by participating in community activities, contributing to projects, or providing value in other recognized ways. The more respect one earns, the more seeds they can generate. These seeds are then used as a currency within the community to trade, barter, or access services and goods offered by other members.

Fungibility from Non-Fungibility

Although each seed is unique (non-fungible) due to its association with individual acts of contribution and the specific context of its issuance, the community can agree to treat these seeds as fungible assets for specific purposes. This agreement allows seeds to be used interchangeably for trading or redeeming services within the community, thus creating a fluid economy where non-fungible tokens acquire fungible properties through communal consensus and utility.

Facilitating Public Goods and Entrepreneurship

Community Gardens provide a fertile ground for public goods creators to monetize their efforts and start businesses within the community framework. By allowing creators to issue seeds based on their contributions, the system enables them to raise funds by offering seeds in exchange for capital, services, or other forms of support. As these seeds can be redeemed for future benefits or services, they represent a form of investment in the creator's work and the community's health. This model encourages sustainable business practices and revenue generation based on shared values and mutual respect.

Summary

In summary, Community Gardens with redeemable seeds offer a robust model for collaboration and economic interaction in digital and decentralized communities. By leveraging the principles of respect and the innovative use of redeemable NFTs, such ecosystems can transform the way we think about value creation, community engagement, and entrepreneurship, particularly in supporting public goods and collective endeavors.

Community Gardens in the digital context are envisioned as platforms where participants can cultivate and grow together by contributing and sharing value, akin to traditional community farming but in a virtual space.

In this system, "seeds" represent redeemable non-fungible tokens (NFTs) that individuals create based on the respect they garner within the community. The respect acts as a metric of one's contributions and determines the quantity of seeds one can generate. This model introduces a concept of fungibility out of non-fungibility, where although each seed (NFT) is unique, they hold equivalent value and utility, making them interchangeable in practice.

This fungibility is achieved through community consensus on the utility and value of these seeds, facilitating a barter-like system within digital communities, supporting public goods creators, and potentially enabling new forms of decentralized business and income opportunities.

The concept of Community Gardens in a digital context refers to collaborative spaces where members of a community can collectively contribute, grow, and share resources. This space functions similarly to a physical community garden but is focused on digital or creative assets rather than agriculture. Within such gardens, members contribute various assets or resources—termed "seeds"—which could represent ideas, digital content, artwork, coding projects, or any form of intellectual property.

A redeemable token, aptly named a "seed," could be used to activate and energize this model of Community Gardens. Here's how it could work:

Creation and Distribution of Seeds

• Seeds are unique digital tokens, potentially structured as non-fungible tokens (NFTs), which represent contributions or value-added assets by individual community members.
• These seeds could be issued based on the contributions members make to the community, such as creating content, developing software, or providing other forms of value.

Redeemable and Fungibility Aspects

• Although seeds start as NFTs (non-fungible and unique), they can be designed to be redeemable for services, goods, or privileges within the community, such as access to exclusive content, use of community resources, or entry into events.
• The fungibility from non-fungibility arises when these seeds are standardized in such a way that they can be exchanged or traded within the community. For example, seeds might carry a nominal value based on the type of contribution they represent, allowing them to be used like currency within the community garden.

Business and Income Opportunities

• Community members can start businesses within or supported by the garden's ecosystem, accepting seeds as a form of payment or investment. For instance, a developer could start a software project within the community, funded by seeds redeemed by other members who believe in the project's potential.
• As seeds are traded and used, they create an internal economy that can support both individual entrepreneurs and community-wide initiatives, helping to fund projects that might be considered public goods.

Benefits of the Model

• Decentralization: Each member has the power to contribute to and benefit from the garden, reducing reliance on central funding sources and distributing power across the community.
• Incentivization: By allowing seeds to be redeemed for real value within the community, members are incentivized to contribute high-quality work and participate actively.
• Innovation and Collaboration: The garden model fosters a collaborative environment where members can support each other's projects and grow their ventures together.

Implementation Considerations

• Value Assessment: The community needs to develop a consensus on how different contributions are valued and how many seeds each type of contribution warrants.
• Redemption Rules: Clear guidelines on how seeds can be redeemed, and for what kind of goods or services, need to be established to ensure fairness and to maintain the token’s value.
• Technology Infrastructure: Using blockchain technology, such as Ethereum, for creating and managing seeds ensures transparency, security, and ease of transferability, enhancing trust among community members.

By integrating these principles, Community Gardens can revolutionize the way creators collaborate, innovate, and monetize their contributions in a decentralized and equitable manner, promoting sustainability and growth of public goods and community-driven businesses.

The concept of Community Gardens in a digital context represents a collaborative ecosystem where members contribute and grow together, much like a traditional garden but focused on digital or intellectual contributions instead of agricultural produce. In this digital garden, the community uses a unique type of token, often referred to as a "seed," which serves as a redeemable non-fungible token (NFT). These seeds can be "planted," that is, invested or spent within the community to foster growth and generate value.

Earning and Using Seeds

Seeds are directly tied to a community member's contributions and the respect they garner within the community. This respect is quantified through a point or token system—individuals earn respect by participating in community activities, contributing to projects, or providing value in other recognized ways. The more respect one earns, the more seeds they can generate. These seeds are then used as a currency within the community to trade, barter, or access services and goods offered by other members.

Fungibility from Non-Fungibility

Although each seed is unique (non-fungible) due to its association with individual acts of contribution and the specific context of its issuance, the community can agree to treat these seeds as fungible assets for specific purposes. This agreement allows seeds to be used interchangeably for trading or redeeming services within the community, thus creating a fluid economy where non-fungible tokens acquire fungible properties through communal consensus and utility.

Facilitating Public Goods and Entrepreneurship

Community Gardens provide a fertile ground for public goods creators to monetize their efforts and start businesses within the community framework. By allowing creators to issue seeds based on their contributions, the system enables them to raise funds by offering seeds in exchange for capital, services, or other forms of support. As these seeds can be redeemed for future benefits or services, they represent a form of investment in the creator's work and the community's health. This model encourages sustainable business practices and revenue generation based on shared values and mutual respect.

Summary

In summary, Community Gardens with redeemable seeds offer a robust model for collaboration and economic interaction in digital and decentralized communities. By leveraging the principles of respect and the innovative use of redeemable NFTs, such ecosystems can transform the way we think about value creation, community engagement, and entrepreneurship, particularly in supporting public goods and collective endeavors.

Community Gardens, Seeds, and Fungibility from Non-Fungibility: Concepts and Opportunities

Community Gardens: The concept of a digital "Community Garden" represents a collective space where individuals contribute and cultivate ideas, much like a traditional garden where people grow plants together. These digital gardens serve as platforms for collaborative growth, innovation, and community development, where members contribute content, ideas, or digital assets that benefit the whole community.

Seeds: In the context of these community gardens, "Seeds" can be considered as individual contributions or digital assets that members bring to the garden. These seeds could be ideas, digital creations, or tokens that represent a form of contribution to the community's overall ecosystem. Members can plant these seeds by introducing them to the community, where they can be nurtured and grown through collaborative efforts.

Fungibility from Non-Fungibility: The idea here revolves around creating fungible assets from non-fungible tokens (NFTs). This approach leverages the unique properties of NFTs but allows them to be used in a way that mimics fungible tokens. By reaching community consensus on certain NFTs that hold value or utility, these NFTs can effectively function as fungible tokens within that community. This system provides a new way to look at the utility and liquidity of NFTs, transforming them from singular, static items into dynamic tools for community engagement and utility.

Together, these concepts offer a fresh framework for how communities can engage with digital assets and contribute to a collective ecosystem. They provide a method for decentralized collaboration and resource sharing that can benefit all participants by leveraging both the unique characteristics of NFTs and the communal strength of traditional governance and economic systems

How can Roles and Reputations project play a role in the concept of Community Gardens? Can it do so and is it a very fitting software for this project?

The Roles and Reputations project can play a crucial role in the concept of Community Gardens by providing a robust framework for recognizing, rewarding, and managing contributions within the community. Here's how it can support this concept and why it's a fitting solution:

How Roles and Reputations Project Can Play a Role in Community Gardens

1. Identifying and Assigning Roles:
• Roles for Gardeners and Supporters: Community Gardens can identify different roles for contributors such as Planters, Cultivators, Seed Distributors, Coordinators, etc.
• Role Assignment: Assign these roles based on individual contributions and the level of respect or reputation earned within the community.
• Specialized Roles: Create specialized roles like "Seed Creator" or "Gardening Advisor" for members who bring specific expertise.
2. Measuring and Recognizing Contributions:
• Reputation Tracking: Track the reputation of members based on the value and impact of their contributions.
• Transparent Recognition: Make contribution recognition transparent so that all community members see how roles and reputations are earned.
3. Incentivizing Positive Contributions:
• Reputation-Based Rewards: Design a system where members earn redeemable tokens (like seeds) based on their roles and reputations.
• Growing Respect for Seeds: Allow members to convert their reputations into Seeds (redeemable NFTs), which can then be used within the Community Garden for various rewards.
• Higher Tier Access: Provide higher-tier access or governance privileges to members with high reputations.
4. Facilitating Collaboration:
• Team Formation: Encourage the formation of specialized teams based on members' roles and expertise, helping coordinate projects like planting or designing new features.
• Cross-Garden Collaboration: Enable collaboration between different Community Gardens by assigning cross-garden roles and sharing reputation scores.

Why Roles and Reputations Project is Fitting for Community Gardens

1. Structured Contribution Management: Provides a clear framework for managing contributions, making it easier to identify active and impactful members.
2. Transparency and Fairness:
• Fair Recognition: Ensures that all contributors are fairly recognized and rewarded based on their impact.
• Transparent Process: Makes the entire contribution and role assignment process transparent.
3. Decentralized and Flexible:
• Decentralized Governance: Enables decentralized governance, with role and reputation scores guiding decision-making.
• Flexible Role System: Allows the creation of custom roles and reward systems tailored to the unique needs of each Community Garden.
4. Encourages Community Growth:
• Incentivizes Contributions: Encourages more people to participate by offering clear rewards for different roles.
• Supports Innovation: Encourages innovation by rewarding creative and impactful contributions.
5. Cross-Community Trust Building:
• Trust Networks: Helps build trust networks across different Community Gardens, allowing them to recognize each other's contributions.

Overall, the Roles and Reputations project is a highly fitting solution for Community Gardens, providing the structure and incentives needed to nurture a thriving, collaborative, and innovative community ecosystem.

How can Hats Protocol play a role in community gardens? Can it do so and is it a very fitting software for this project?

Hats Protocol can play a transformative role in the concept of Community Gardens within decentralized networks by facilitating structured participation and contribution tracking. Here’s how it could be applied and its suitability for this purpose:

How Hats Protocol Can Contribute to Community Gardens

1. Tokenized Roles and Responsibilities:
• Specific Gardening Roles: Hats Protocol can be used to create specific roles within a Community Garden, such as Garden Planner, Watering Coordinator, or Pest Management Lead. These roles can be represented by tokenized hats, each conferring specific permissions and responsibilities.
• Role Fluidity: As community members' involvement or expertise grows, their roles can evolve. New hats can be issued to reflect new roles or additional responsibilities, while less active roles can be revoked or replaced, ensuring dynamic participation aligns with the community’s needs.
2. Access Control and Resource Management:
• Resource Allocation: Use hats to manage access to gardening resources such as tools, plots, or special supplies. Only community members with the appropriate hat can access certain resources, ensuring that they are used responsibly and by those with the right skills.
• Activity Logging and Permissioning: Automate the logging of gardening activities based on role ownership. For example, only those with a Watering Coordinator hat can modify the watering schedule, enhancing accountability and transparency.
3. Incentives and Rewards:
• Rewarding Participation: Distribute hats as rewards for community engagement and contributions, such as consistent participation in gardening activities or taking on extra responsibilities.
• Incentive Structures: Create incentives where accumulating specific hats can lead to greater privileges, such as decision-making power in the garden's development or access to premium resources.
4. Governance and Decision-Making:
• Governance Rights: Assign hats that come with voting rights or the ability to propose changes to the Community Garden’s policies. This ensures that decision-making is kept within a group of actively involved and knowledgeable participants.
• Automated Governance Actions: Use the protocol to automate certain governance actions, such as the enforcement of community rules or the scheduling of maintenance tasks, based on the distribution and consensus of relevant hat holders.

Suitability of Hats Protocol for Community Gardens

1. Flexibility and Customizability:
• Hats Protocol’s flexible nature allows for the creation of a variety of roles tailored to the specific needs and structures of different Community Gardens, making it highly adaptable to various community setups.
2. Scalability:
• As the community grows and the garden expands, the protocol can scale to accommodate more participants and more complex roles without losing effectiveness, making it suitable for Community Gardens that anticipate growth.
3. Decentralization and Community Empowerment:
• By decentralizing role management and automating certain aspects of garden governance, Hats Protocol empowers community members to take active roles in managing their environment, aligning with the grassroots ethos of Community Gardens.
4. Interoperability:
• Given that Hats Protocol uses ERC-1155 tokens, these roles can be integrated with other Ethereum-based applications and services, potentially linking Community Gardens with broader ecosystems involving environmental initiatives, local currencies, or decentralized autonomous organizations (DAOs).

Hats Protocol is thus not only suitable but could be highly beneficial for Community Gardens within decentralized networks, providing a structured, scalable, and flexible system to manage participation, resources, and governance in a community-driven and empowering manner.

rry some of your thoughts and the last one I'll introduce is starting a community garden uh this I don't know if there's an example of this I mean in 1:13:11 a way there's an example this is kind of how communities have grown for a very long time people have had Gardens and 1:13:17 farms and they've grown things together and that has helped communities um Thrive you know for thousands of years 1:13:23 really in many ways and has enabled all these different things but we don't really have digital Community Gardens we 1:13:29 have on edencreators.com I have edencrest.com Garden where I write a lot of notes uh there and I think that can 1:13:34 kind of evolve into what I'm thinking here but really like a community garden that's just been a project that I've been doing and Rosemary's also been 1:13:40 helping a lot with this too uh cac's helped out with an article or two there as well but we can grow it into a much 1:13:46 different way and I think that we have an opportunity I had a conversation with the Das this week that was very inspiring that also written an article 1:13:52 called fungibility ad non-fungible tokens um that he wrote this in October of 2022 1:13:58 after the Genesis fractal disbanded there's also an article from Andrew Ware about like personal respect or something 1:14:04 like that that's related I have an article about it that I haven't pulled up yet um it is a little bit confusing so ask himself so there's a little bit 1:14:09 confusing when he first wrote this and took me a while to wrap my head around it but now I think that this article 1:14:15 provides a pretty key to solution for how we can raise funding for everybody in the community and do it in a way that 1:14:21 I think it provides the best of both of all worlds really I think inspired generation of entrepreneurs get people 1:14:27 um provide people opportunities for funding in the relatively short term there might be some things that we need to build it goes amazingly for 1:14:33 storytelling with the Eden fractal and gardening um and I think it provides an a huge new 1:14:40 level of decentralization in tadasa's article that he wrote here um just as a high level overview he had 1:14:47 written um that to create a fungible token you don't need an issue you don't need a protocol that anyone can follow to issue 1:14:53 nfts that can become part of the fungible token set and this reveals the power of human consensus a community is able to reach consensus on this set of 1:15:00 nfts at respects and provide utilities for creates a federal ground a fertile ground a gardening metaphor for 1:15:05 ecosystem to create a fungible token for them by treating their respected entities as fungible effectively you 1:15:10 have a fungible token with an unlimited amount of independent issuers this is um this is another level of 1:15:16 decentralization so whereas the system laid out in the frackfully white paper 1:15:21 it has basically one token that people can respect for each community I believe that what we can do here is we 1:15:28 can start a community garden uh where everybody can create their own seeds we 1:15:33 can call them seeds um they're nfts people can create a different amount of seeds depending on 1:15:38 the ranks that they get in each weekly meeting uh and then people can accept these seeds um as a way to share goods 1:15:45 and services both in planting them or and giving them to each other or selling them into each other in different ways 1:15:50 so I can go much more detail with this I've been writing a lot about it and it's not fully prepared yet um I started writing 1:15:56 I started curating some art I just wrote a little bit that's kind of like a very high little overview um so maybe it's confusing right now I'm 1:16:03 happy to go in more detail I see tadas just shared uh more ideas in the live chat too so I'll maybe pass this to us 1:16:08 in a moment uh and encourage everybody to read that I'll also just say to um these are some links I shared one 1:16:13 other thing that I just heard about yesterday from a member of the enonios community uh was this one called 1:16:19 nounsdale it's in ethereum and this this has a different system so we wouldn't do anything quite like this but it has some 1:16:25 very interesting inspiration they have a system where they sell one nft every day their nfts look like these characters 1:16:30 with these glasses they're kind of goofy and funky and fun and stuff like that uh they sell FTS for approximately 30 each 1:16:36 every day uh which is something like sixty thousand dollars or so and then they use this to create like really high 1:16:42 quality content and videos like the funded documentaries they funded public goods uh code development and so forth 1:16:48 and this woman here she has a really interesting uh intro video about how she 1:16:53 got um like funding to create an acapella where they talk about nouns and stuff uh so it's really interesting it's 1:17:00 quite well done uh it provides a lot of opportunities and ideas about how nfts can help communities grow and I think 1:17:07 there's a lot we can learn from them so I just wanted to introduce that briefly as well uh but yeah really I just wanted 1:17:12 to kick off the discussion see what everything's I can go in more detail about this community garden people have questions or want to discuss whatever is 1:17:18 here and I'm really excited to share more details about you thank you all for listening I will stop my screen share 1:17:24 here and uh if anybody has any thoughts about happy Behavior perhaps to us I see you're on camera now if you want to follow up on that first then we're happy 1:17:31 to hear from you um yeah just yes thanks Dan Tadas elaborates on article he wrote, design principle to create a fungible token without actually having a fungible token. Gives details 1:17:37 thanks Paul and thanks for presenting my idea yeah so let the 1:17:43 article fungibility of the non-fungible tokens it's uh 1:17:50 like we then said I I think it's not I would write it a bit differently 1:17:57 right now I don't I think it's people don't and there's kind of three level 1:18:03 and uh yeah the point of this article is to present 1:18:09 the general idea for uh yeah later I present an example of 1:18:14 implementation but it's more of an example and I'm not suggesting actually 1:18:20 doing that but yeah my point is that that there are certain 1:18:27 design principles which we could use to create uh 1:18:33 a fungible token without actually issuing a fungible token 1:18:38 so seems like like uh like magic but it's it's really 1:18:44 simple principles which have which have analogies in real life like for example 1:18:51 uh let's take real physical cash every 1:18:56 dollar bill is unique so every dollar bill is in sort of an nft 1:19:02 uh yet we consider them fungible we consider about one dollar bill is 90 1:19:11 dollar bill is interchangeable with any other uh so this means that it's our 1:19:19 uh we we basically have consensus as a society to treat them as as unique if 1:19:26 they have certain properties we can apply the same principles here so 1:19:32 imagine that anyone could issue an nft but if if 1:19:41 it satisfies certain requirements for example in a way that that nft was 1:19:47 issued then some utility provider service provider 1:19:52 chooses to to provide services for burning that nft 1:19:58 so now you have a full class of nfts for which you can have certain utility 1:20:04 so we basically have set up an environment which incentivizes the market to treat 1:20:13 that's that of nft and if this as the fungible because each unit of them each 1:20:20 nft in that set provides some unit of utility 1:20:26 so and it's possible I think to to design a smart contract which you would 1:20:31 take nfts and present an interface of a fungible token 1:20:39 so that's the general idea and there are still some uh details lacking here but yeah then it 1:20:49 required requires more work to to to like to answer questions like what do 1:20:56 you would be the utility like who would be able to create those nfts 1:21:02 and so on but yeah my idea is to pre to just to Jorge asks Dan tools used, AI generated. Gives his perspective on opines with nfts. 1:21:10 share this because it will take me a lot of time just to come with us with a design so I I would welcome anyone who 1:21:17 could help me be in researching in this direction 1:21:23 and I think it's clear like what what are the benefits of that of that is it's 1:21:29 that the issuance of this uh 1:21:35 fungible type of token which is created out of nft the issuance would be totally 1:21:43 much more decentralized and I think much harder to attack legally like from the regulator 1:21:50 perspective 1:21:55 thank you so much great points um I have a lot to share there 1:22:01 um I see Perry and meet it but Jorge's hand up so if you want to go next ferry then I'll pass it to you but first we'll 1:22:06 go over to Jorge 1:22:12 all right you wanna share some thoughts here or do you love your hand do I go first 1:22:20 I'm sorry what's that Jorge do you want to go first it's up to you if you want to go first 1:22:27 thank you yeah sounds like really interesting first of all it done a question for you 1:22:34 those images in your presentation you made them using 1:22:39 the AI now I use those using mid-journey uh which is similar to Dolly but uh benefit 1:22:46 of mid-journey is that you can use them for more commercial applications and stuff like that Dolly too has uh like 1:22:52 more copyright restrictions and stuff like that mid journey I just got the like the plan and tried it out this 1:22:58 month is awesome tool okay but it was AI 1:23:04 supported AI supported yeah and I did a couple tweaks to add titles and stuff 1:23:10 although one image I made myself personally last year but the rest were AI generated yeah 1:23:15 regarding tadas um it does look really interesting 1:23:22 I remember reading the paper initially but I didn't fully unders through the implications so 1:23:29 it's like if any person could emit some shares of 1:23:35 himself and the market would decide what price to give to those shares like like if any 1:23:43 person will be it come a kind of mini corporations so that for 1:23:49 example we know we love all Rosemary so we want to pop 1:23:55 the nfts that she emitted and depending on the relative value of each 1:24:02 nft we could exchange products and services like buying a coffee or 1:24:08 any other product using those different nfts from different persons like 1:24:13 exchanging different pools or shares from corporations for other products it's not 1:24:20 the idea like bearing on the performance of individual 1:24:25 people not quite so the key here is that the 1:24:35 utility provider would set requirements for or utility provider provider or a 1:24:41 fractal would set requirements for an nft that will and would would have to 1:24:47 ensure that it's not just randomly it's not like anyone could randomly 1:24:54 create as much of eligible nfts as possible 1:24:59 uh so maybe an example would serve better so Tadas gives example of how it would work 1:25:05 uh yeah so 1:25:10 so imagine that so we are talking about I'm calling this 1:25:15 this set of nfts which provide some utility eligible nfts so nfts which 1:25:24 are eligible to to to provide utility they are burned 1:25:29 uh yeah so we could say that in order to create an eligible nft the account that creates it 1:25:37 has to have a respect balance in from mid and fractal 1:25:42 and say the amount of nfts that he can create like this would be proportionate 1:25:49 to the amount of respect that he learned earned the last week 1:25:55 yeah so this way total supply of these eligible nfts 1:26:03 would be limited 1:26:09 thank you deep 1:26:15 thank you very much for handing us uh if you guys don't have any further comments then I suppose we can pass on to Perry Perry comments it’s a form of barter system, details his opinion 1:26:20 now well I I haven't I had a chance to read 1:26:26 the article but what I'm what I'm hearing is very interesting 1:26:31 and I'm hearing like a form of almost it's a mix of a form of a barter system 1:26:38 it's like it's like a a formal border 1:26:46 with nft and 1:26:51 it's interesting because what we're trying to do I mean let's befriend what we're trying to do 1:26:57 is avoid all the legal issues and 1:27:03 farmer is not illegal everywhere 1:27:08 and and there are some models that are accepted 1:27:14 that not necessarily your partner but are but are acceptable models 1:27:20 of exchanging value and one of them one of the interesting ones to me is the 1:27:26 high Art Market you know these where these expensive pieces of art are auctioned 1:27:33 off and that is well known to be a way that the very wealthy 1:27:39 store their their their wealth and they've done it for years 1:27:45 it's a very it's a very bizarre Market right I mean how 1:27:50 it's very strange where where somebody with a lot of money can go in and 1:27:56 they among themselves they can bid up the price of a particular piece of art 1:28:02 and they're you know they're essentially storing 22 million dollars in something 1:28:08 that they either keep in their home or they keep in a vault and then they can take that 1:28:15 and over time it can it can raise in value and then they can resell it 1:28:20 and that's okay that's perfectly legal but yet aren't a group like ours has to 1:28:29 kind of think creatively of how we can just trade among ourselves 1:28:36 so I'm interested in in hearing that article and and I gotta say to us I mean with this 1:28:43 idea and the idea that you introduced today uh regarding Dows on an evm 1:28:50 and then the week before the idea that you you introduced with the with the tree 1:28:56 you're just a a machine right now you're just coming up with all kinds of great ideas I don't think you have enough time 1:29:05 I don't know what you're going to do with all these I think it's great that you're coming up with them but wow we 1:29:11 need to get some we need to get some developers under you do you have anybody working for you 1:29:17 nope um developers group if anyone wants to help 1:29:24 you out yeah good idea I will I should do that 1:29:30 yeah so some of these most of these ideas are actually I I've been 1:29:35 uh I came up with this a lot earlier and now I'm just sharing them and I already 1:29:40 shared most of them it's just that it's hard to 1:29:46 to to well maybe I didn't spend enough enough time like like sharing in one of 1:29:51 the right places but yeah to get through to people 1:29:57 well yeah thanks a lot for uh the feedback uh Perry and tadas I agree we 1:30:04 should definitely uh aim to help support dasa's ideas and help raise my funding as well as everybody in the community Dan comments on discussion, agrees we are trying to avoid legal issues. Details his plan on how it would work and implementing. Gardening and growing, planting seeds(Ceeds) 1:30:10 here and we all kind of are working for each other too and helping promote it too but yeah for sure we can grow and that's kind of a big part of this discussion about how do we grow and how 1:30:17 do we fund each other and stuff like that um I see Jorge has a hands up I think I could also jump in with a couple comments too or a new audience for us 1:30:25 yeah just before to finish off with before daddy said 1:30:30 that thanks for introducing the concept of barter I think it's 1:30:36 it's I haven't thought about that but I think it might be useful 1:30:44 great yeah I agree to uh Perry was there anything else if you want anything else then feel free to jump in or if not I'll 1:30:50 go and not pass out of worry afterwards that was it thank you okay cool and yeah 1:30:55 if you do want to go first then you can feel free but I think it might be hopeful for me to jump in with some comments here and then I can pass on to 1:31:01 you afterwards sound good yeah okay cool uh yeah so 1:31:08 I wanted to write a bit of context the whole presentation I I if I had more time I would like to prepare it better 1:31:13 because I kind of put it together quickly uh but I've been thinking about this idea a lot since I had the conversation with the Dasa on Saturday 1:31:19 and I've been following this idea I have another page that I'm curating for the past like since October since tadas 1:31:24 wrote that I read a couple of times and then I wrote um I think maybe at edencares.com funding or something like that there's 1:31:30 also a similar article by Andrew Ware that I'll find and I'll share too so I've been thinking about it and I didn't know how to make it work 1:31:37 um and then yeah the conversation with tadas was really fascinating um and it inspired me greatly over the 1:31:43 past few days uh and so I wanted to share a bit more context about where I'm at with it and what I'm thinking we can do 1:31:49 um so the one thing Perry said what we're trying to do is avoid legal issues which uh I agree I mean it's true we're 1:31:55 trying to cooperate in a manner where we're keeping everybody safe and it's compliance the equal numbers like that we don't want people get in trouble but 1:32:01 at the same time it's also so much more than that too I think I think it's way more um and this is you know I I just been 1:32:07 thinking of this idea for the past few days but as far as I can see right now and maybe I'll think about something maybe I'll realize a flaw in it later 1:32:12 something like that but to me it seems like this is a far better way of cooperating than was originally defined 1:32:17 in the faculty white paper um and I have immense respect to factory paper I basically changed my like entire 1:32:22 life and you know it inspired me to do all this and transpectively only worlds all these different things stem from the 1:32:28 factory white paper um and this is taking a lot of the principles from the back of the white paper a lot of things we've been doing but it just binds a better model that 1:32:35 both makes it more uh safe for everybody and reduces risk of 1:32:40 legal issues as you said there's a standard for people trading and bartering and stuff like that and that's commonly accepted that people 1:32:48 you know sharing their art with the world sharing their their things that they're doing to help the world and selling like that that's a that's a 1:32:53 public good that's a moral good and anybody who tries to stop that is doing something that's not right 1:32:58 um and generally speaking you know just general terms here like that's a common thing so say thing keeping people safe is a good thing uh but then also too 1:33:05 like tadas made a great point that um in that article I said about increasing decent centralization to me it seems 1:33:11 that this has potential to be orders of magnitude more decentralized than the originally proposed way of having a 1:33:17 single respect token that was originally proposed in the factory white paper rather than having one Center Point uh 1:33:23 where there potentially could be you know everybody's oh let's get let's see who's gonna admit the most respect tokens or whatever everybody has the 1:33:29 ability to uh do their own thing and the way I've been identifying it too so I've 1:33:34 been working on a lot of branding uh for how we can introduce This Disaster that is burning nfts 1:33:40 um I'd suggest on the call with the Das and then I worked on a lot with rosemary Rosemary brought the up TDA because she was like what are you writing nfts and 1:33:45 all this stuff uh so yeah but I think the best way to uh to 1:33:50 describe it especially because we're eating fractal is gardening and growing and so instead of burning afts we're planting seeds 1:33:56 I'm working on building like a brand around this and building a way to explain it that I think will go really well with a great story um um and I 1:34:04 think it will work quite well to help us grow amazing things together so in addition to being more safe from 1:34:10 regulations it's also way more decentralized and way more empowering for the individual too like it provides more utility I have a lot of thoughts 1:34:17 about how we could uh figured the specifics and perhaps we can meet I'm happy to hear uh 1:34:22 everybody's thoughts and discuss this more in detail but have a lot of ideas about how we can Define these I think it could be fairly simple uh and I think it 1:34:29 could motivate people to promote their own work while promoting everybody else's work too and provide great ways 1:34:34 to support people in the community like I think uh Perry or uh Jorge I guess mentioned supporting Rose Marie's 1:34:40 excellent work with uh buying MTS or buying seeds and I think we do the same thing for everybody in the community and 1:34:45 it could be a way that people can be inspired to go like to other chats and share their nfts share their seeds while 1:34:51 also promoting the whole group at the same time um so I'll share more details about that but I wanted to write a bit more context 1:34:56 basically I think we can turn this into a game where everyone at factory meeting can create nfts or seeds together and 1:35:02 it's a like a really amazing way to support each other that it's a potentially a huge Innovation that can 1:35:07 uh really help us out in so many ways so anyway uh I know Jorge has their hand had his hands up so if you still want to 1:35:14 share some thoughts Jorge then uh be happy to hear from you I see Noam shared a comment too if you want to share that 1:35:19 out loud after Jorge perhaps afterwards no then we'd be happy for me too I 1:35:25 writing it was enough it took me a while to write it and I okay cool sounds good 1:35:30 if you want to share that in uh the telegram chat too I don't know if you did that or just the uh yeah okay great 1:35:36 thank you I I also shared uh a quote on they're 1:35:42 both on the general telegram chat model live chat okay oops sounds great 1:35:49 thank you no I'm looking forward to reading it thoughts that pop into my head when I'm listening to all you guys talking 1:35:55 cool thanks so much uh Jorge did you still want to share 1:36:01 some thoughts here yeah two things first uh I do believe Jorge on the need for more developers 1:36:09 that we need more Developers and we need to reduce our cost