rationale
This could be a big value add for OF and OTH to create big impact when help us earn more in retro funding
This mechanics could be reused for many other types of group voting, Ie on retro funding projects or metrics
This could help us make better shows and events that are more enjoyable and effective
This can be also used by Eden fractal and all other communities
UX issues
It seems to be too complex in the current iteration
There’s not much engagement in topic proposing or suggesting yet
It takes a long time to explain and sometimes even get confused about how it works
It’d not stable yet and changes from week to week
I like both the cagendas and Optopics brands, but it might confuse people to have two game names
the original rules of Cagendas are very simple and easy to explain/understand, but they are limited in that they only allow one topic to be chosen and
technical issues
Snapshot currently doesn’t enable seeing the amount of votes at a certain time unless the poll ends at that time. This doesn’t work with the current implementation of cagendas and the predictability of topic selection on mondays
Snapshot doesn’t seem to allow you to rank order multiple polls in a space or allocate a limited amount of weight across polls. This means that either everyone can reuse their votes across all polls (which gives excessive power to people with more respect) or one person needs to create a singe poll to allow people to allocate a limited amount of votes across topics, which requires action from one person, requires a poll to be created at a certain time which makes it inflexible for topic suggestions after that time, and limits interactivity on the platform . This
Send Message to Snapshot Discord to ask about desired features
Review Methods for Voting with Respect in Notion and Snapshot via the Notion API
solutions
Further writing this documentation page will helP A lot so I can see all the issues in one place
Try linking the previous pages here as well so it can reference related research
JokeRace may solve these. Think about how it’s used by Diana Chen for the podcast where anyone can suggest a guest and then vote on the guest- I think we could use a similar mechanic for topics that jokerace allows and isn’t possible on snapshot
It’s also possible that tally could solve these and it’s prob worth trying it as well, though jokerace seems preferable
Ask in the snapshot discord
If jokerace or tally don’t work out of the box, Create a product requirement document and share it with the discord/telegrAm Of snapshot/ jokerace/ tally to see if they know how to make it work or what custom dev would be required